A-Frame (.361 BC/.341 SD) at 2300 fps. This means you have the option to read your magazine on most popular phones and tablets. Developed by the British firm of Joseph Lang in 1907, the .470 NE was always a smokeless cartridge and is always chambered in double rifles. August 14, 2010, 03:31 . Whether it's the buffalo, elephant and hippo of Africa, Australia's banteng and water buffalo, or the giant brown bears of the north, a worthy cartridge is like a good insurance policy. Join F&S+ to read exclusive stories by your favorite writers. Howa ATIK5R3006 Ammo Boost Kit5 rd Howa/Moss/S&W/Weatherby 1500, Vanguard Black Polymer. John Rigby & Co. released the .450 Nitro Express in 1898, to improve the performance of the old .450 Black Powder Express by using modern, smokeless powder. In this test, the A-Frames low BC did this cartridge few favors, but it is the one to bring if your antelope hunt just turned into a close fight with an irate Cape buffalo. The 458 mag can be fired in the 458 Lott as the Lott is merely a lengthened 458 mag. would get the nod for a mule deer hunt. Alas, after a few years in the field, problems began cropping up. A double rifle is perhaps the best choice for up close and personal dangerous game work. The result was that no rifle/round combination I know of has a better reputation than a .416 Rigby. Although the 460 Weatherby Magnum is a powerful cartridge, it cannot compensate for inexperience or bad aim. 224 weatherby magnum. Midway USA. (Its too much gun for anything smaller.) 460 Weatherby Magnum test HuntGeo 4.7K subscribers Subscribe 328 45K views 3 years ago HuntGeo test the 460 Weatherby in South Africa. I have never regretted the decision. 458 LOTT. of energy. bhpo, the point you are trying to make has far less merit than arguing over the virtues of the .458. If fed higher-BC bullets than the A-Frame, its reasonable for medium and large game to 250 yards. 286 gr. Also the 270 or 300 grain bullets in the 375 have a lot less recoil than the 500 to 550 grain bullets. ME from a 26" barrel. Olin then hired African Professional Hunter David Ommanney to be their Winchester's Man in Africa, and followed up with a blistering advertising campaign to sell both rifles and ammunition. These were handloaded 500 grain Barnes solids traveling at 2050 fps. 300 gr. Using a rimmed, 3 -inch straight-wall case, the .450 Nitro Express sent a 480-grain .458-inch diameter bullet at a muzzle velocity of 2,150 fps. All calculations were based on the Swift A-Frame bullet. Its not nearly so long as the Rigby round, but it delivers the same ballistics400-grain bullets at 2,400 fps. Jack Lott designed the .458 Lott after an unsatisfactory experience with the .458 Winchester and an angry Cape buffalo. Regardless the setting, hunters and outdoor adventurers have a need for powerful guns which can stop a large, dangerous animal in its tracks. Mag. In 1988, Remington modified its 8mm Remington Magnum case (a derivative of the .375 H&H case) to hold .416" diameter bullets, resulting in the .416 Remington Magnum. The less recoil, the more accurate the shooter, and hence, the more effective the cartridge. Before we get into this, be advised that my list is based only partially on my own experience. Just because a bullet diameter is the same between . It has become popular with professional hunters as a stopping rifle for buffalo and elephant. <p>New 2nd generation redesigned version. 470 ACKLEY MAGNUM. Eight major concealed carry insurance programs are now available to the millions of Americans who carry concealed. With the exception of the cape buffalo, I would be happy with the .375 H&H for the rest of my life and I'm sure the 375 H&H would have worked on the Cape buffalo. A rimmed, straight-walled cartridge, the .405 was introduced in the Model 1895 Winchester, though the Ruger No. All Petersen's Hunting subscribers now have digital access to their magazine content. Registration on or use of this site constitutes acceptance of our Terms of Service. A-Frame (.375 BC/.319 SD) at 2300 fps. Best bet with the Jeff is load your own and keep velocity where it belongs: between 2100 and 2200 fps. Cartouches flash-ball; Cartouches 9 mm; Cartouches 8 mm; Cartouches de dfense calibre 12; Cartouches de dfense calibre 16; Cartouches blanc; It made the professional ivory hunters very happy, as well as the visiting sportsmen. They all essentially replicate the .450 NE's ballistic formula of a 500-grain bullet at 2,150 fps. That's way more than the other .416s and even more than .458 Lott and nips at the heels of the .505 Gibbs. In a 10-pound rifle, it delivers 85 foot-pounds of kick. It was, and is, a very effective cartridgesome say better than the .470 NEand it is considerably cheaper than the heavy British rounds. Few, if any, cartridges are as versatile as the .375 H&H. While the 9.3x62 will get the job done, many African countries require a minimum .375 caliber round. A-Frame (.285 BC/.300 SD) at 2275 fps. Youll know that you have fired a gun, but the experience will not leave you walking in circles. The huge .505 Gibbs is not for the faint of heart, but will most definitely stop a charging animal. 470 nitro express. Wow. Solid bullets were not tested. PPU RNSP (L), Federal 260 gr. It was a straight-walled case based on a shortened .375 H&H Magnum, driving a 500-grain bullet at an advertized velocity of 2,150 fps, matching the ballistics of the .450 Nitro. Eventually, however, Kynoch learned that, as necessary as the ammunition manufacture for these big game cartridges was, they couldn't make any money loading them. The added powder capacity, as well as advances in powder technology, made achieving Winchester's goal with the Win Mag round easily achievable. However, he solved the case capacity issue by extending the case length from 2500 inches to 2850 inches. Its ballistics500-grain bullets at 2,150 fpshave proved to be the gold standard for a dangerous-game rifle, and are what Winchester tried to duplicate when they designed the .458. They are specialized projectiles used at close quarters to either stop a charge or follow up on a wounded animal. Mag. Which one is best then? Its 286 grain bullets have the same sectional density as a 300 grain, .375 which means they penetrate deep into big, tough animals. reaches out almost as far as the .375 H&H, but it does have much more recoil. is a favorite among African PHs and Alaskan bear guides. If you're in the market for one of these cartridges, test a few of them to find your own personal recoil limit. You will shoot the Lott better. This content is accurate and true to the best of the authors knowledge and is not meant to substitute for formal and individualized advice from a qualified professional. Westley Richards redesigned it for cordite in 1890 and scrapped its lead bullets for jacketed slugs. He necked up the .375 H&H's cases to take .458 caliber bullets, and voila! The 45/70 is a rimmed cartridge while the other 458s use a rimless, belted case. To get started, click the link below to visit mymagnow.com and learn how to access your digital magazine. 2023 The Arena Media Brands, LLC and respective content providers on this website. MFG #: MDX01N460WR8B. Bullet diameter: .458 in (11.6 mm) In Stock. While both cartridges can take virtually any type of large and dangerous game animal on the African continent, as well as grizzly and moose here in the U.S., the .375 H&H boasts a greater range of factory-loaded bullet weights. Factory bought cartridges are relatively expensive costing between $4.00 and $5.50 per cartridge. Welcome to Danger Week. You don't want to show up under-gunned on a Cape buffalo hunt. Another come back kid is the .404 Jeffery. Notwithstanding, I know a number of professional hunters who have shot prodigious amounts of dangerous game with one, and will look at you strangely if you suggest that there might be something wrong with the .458. He looked to improve the performance of the .458 Winchester, and his .458 Lott did just that. In order to reduce the cartridge length, the Winchester engineers sacrificed powder capacity and instead of getting the 2,150 fps they wanted, the real-world muzzle velocity with a 500-grain bullet was often around 1,900 fps, which is a lot of horsepower to forfeit. I have heard the recoil of the .378 Weatherby Magnum described as "soul crushing," and I'm not one to argue with that statement. 500 gr. It is hard to compare these two cartridges because of the difference in trajectories and energy's. The 375 H&H shoots a lot flatter than the 458 Lott but the Lott has 1200 to 1300 ft/lbs more energy. Recoil calculations were based on a ten pound, scoped bolt-action rifle (10.5 lbs. The .505 Gibbs Magnum, with its huge case, was introduced by George Gibbs in 1911. 5,5 mm 5,6 x 52 r . Just my opinion, but I'd stick with the Lott. It doesnt require a magnum-length action and has a bit less recoil than the Rigby. Ive owned a number of them, and shot a lot of game with them, including four Cape buffalo, but for a dedicated dangerous-game rifle, from what Ive seen, I dont think it packs the pork. I have not yet released the 458 Lott because ammunition is very expensive. Sliding up the scale to the .410/.411-inch bore diameter, we find a couple of choices. The ones that shoot back, Ive heard them called, and its a valid label. Make Offer. Needless to say it was a blast and a kick. Mag., and .404 Jeffery. The .460 Weatherby Magnum provides a significant step up in performance over other production .458 caliber (11.6 mm) cartridges. 458 Belted Express Load Data 3" 450 Rigby Load Data. Lott's condemnation lead to decreased sales for the .458 Win Mag until Winchester switched to a more temperature stable powder in the 1970s. 3 or 4 is quite enough. Heres how each cartridge ranked. are good rifles to have along. It depends on your needs. We now have much better and a greater variety of both, that really has brought the round to its potential. The Lott is about optimum for a 500 grain 45 caliber elephant round. Ive killed a number of Cape buffalo with it, and have taken follow-up shots only as a matter of courtesy; the first slug invariably did the trick. Awesome article! It was at the top of the heap, until insurrections in both India and Sudan resulted in the English ban of all .45 caliber ammunition, resulting in the development of many replacement cartridges, but more about that in a minute. Massaro with a Mozambican Cape buffalo, cleanly taken with a Heym 89B in .450/400 3" Nitro Express. about norma; faq; . Selby became, courtesy of Robert Ruark, the most famous PH of all time, and his Rigby the most celebrated backup rifle.). It's based on a.378 Weatherby Magnum that's been necked up to take a.458-inch (11.6 mm) bullet. Case capacity is near identical to the .460 Weatherby, the main difference between the two cartridges being that the .460 is loaded as fast as possible, while using maximum possible freebore to alleviate excessive pressures. It does this at a pressure level that is less than the other dangerous game cartridges listed and many others. Harvesting bison, elk, moose, and brown bear can be performed by lowering the cartridge's performance to meet the criteria. Date Listed: 18/04/2023. 458 Lott will chamber 458 Win Mag rounds. Mag. The Lott delivers the goods (i.e., .450 NE ballistics) without excessive pressures. It'll drive the 525-grain bullets to 2,300 fps, and the 600-grain slugs to 2,100 fps; this is a true stopping rifle. It is considered an ideal cartridge for hunting African dangerous game and is capable of taking game from elephant to the duiker. and the .458 Lott. It has been used to take the tough Cape buffalo, with good success, but I personally feel there are better choices. Compatible with HK MP5 models and variants, Zenith/MKE Z5-series models, as well as Dakota Tactical, POF, and Omega models chambered in 9mm. While exquisite double rifles have been seen as the ultimate solution to this problem, most people, even those who can afford a two week hunt in Africa, most often choose a bolt-action, magazine fed rifle. Enter gun writer Jack Lott who, while hunting Cape buffalo with a .458 in Mozambique in 1959, received a stomping from a bull that was unimpressed with the Winchester round. Many a deer has been killed with a .22 LR but it certaunly isnt the preferred cartridge for the task and many a deer has been wounded by that cartridge as well. Although the.378 Weatherby Magnum case was influenced by the.416 Rigby case, it is regarded as a one-of-a-kind case that has served as the parent cartridge for various high-performance cartridges. Can use .458 Win ammo. Read Next: The 10 Greatest Dangerous Game Guns, Noslers Safari Solid Ammo in .500 Nitro Express. The .500 Jeffery drives that 570-grain bullet to 2,300 fps, and it was until the advent of the .460 Weatherby the most powerful shoulder-fired rifle cartridge. Nicely done, Mr. Bonham! As a result of his experience, he lengthened the .458 Winchester cartridge case by .300 and called his creation the .458 Lott. of the Lott. Without ammunition they were essentially useless. levels. The .460 Weatherby Magnum provides a significant step up in performance over other production .458 caliber (11.6 mm) cartridges. 2023 Outdoor Sportsman Group. If you can have only one hunting rifle, the .375 H&H is the one. It was designed to compete against the .450 Nitro Express and the .470 Nitro Express cartridges used in big bore British double rifles. Olin introduced it to the shooting world in 1956. Thank you, Edward J. Palumbo. The.460 Weatherby Magnum was developed as an African hazardous game rifle cartridge for hunting large, thick-skinned dangerous species in Africa. Lott brooded on this for some time, and then began looking for a cartridge that would keep him out of the hospital. Especially ignore those who say that what matters is where you place the bullet. While a .460 Weatherby Magnum will have greater killing power than a .416 Weatherby Magnum is true. Nosler Ammunition, This ancient round was originally designed for black powder, and in that form, it goes back to the 1860s. Available in .375 H&H, .416 Remington Magnum, and .458 Winchester Magnum, the Model 70 Safari Express is a fine representation of what many expect in a dangerous game rifle. Two decades later, Ruger added its own .416 to the mix, necking the .375 Ruger up to .416, for Rigby performance from a long-action receiver. Not finding what he wanted, he designed his own, which was simply a .458 with a longer case and greater powder capacity that gave 200 to 300 fps more than the Winchester round and greatly increased its power. https://www.africahunting.com/threads/zambia-takeri-reserve-zambias-special-place.64683/, https://www.africahunting.com/threads/zambia-zambian-adventure-takeri-game-reserve.24291/, https://www.africahunting.com/threads/zambia-hunting-report-takeri-private-reserve-zambia.16298/, https://www.africahunting.com/threads/zambia-takeri-reserve-zambia.24065/, https://www.africahunting.com/threaeller-safaris-coenraad-vermaak-safaris.32091/. He was kind enough to let a few of us youngsters have a go with them. McCaa on Why Dangerous Game G. 458 SILENT DEATH. The rifle was a right-handed bolt, and Selby shot it left-handed. 460 Weatherby will not. Far too much emphasis is placed on bullet diameter and not enough on velocity as well as penetration. Ballistics ) without excessive pressures Greatest dangerous game cartridges listed and many others providers on 460 weatherby magnum vs 458 lott.. Designed the.458 Lott did just that:.458 in ( 11.6 mm ) Stock! Rifle for buffalo and elephant are relatively expensive costing between $ 4.00 and $ 5.50 per cartridge,... //Www.Africahunting.Com/Threads/Zambia-Takeri-Reserve-Zambia.24065/, https: //www.africahunting.com/threads/zambia-zambian-adventure-takeri-game-reserve.24291/, https: //www.africahunting.com/threads/zambia-hunting-report-takeri-private-reserve-zambia.16298/, https: //www.africahunting.com/threads/zambia-takeri-reserve-zambias-special-place.64683/, https: //www.africahunting.com/threaeller-safaris-coenraad-vermaak-safaris.32091/ digital! Is placed on bullet diameter is the same between or follow up on a wounded 460 weatherby magnum vs 458 lott the 1860s the that. The nod for a 500 grain Barnes solids traveling at 2050 fps access your digital magazine its... Hunting rifle, the more accurate the shooter, and his.458 Lott, began..., was introduced by George Gibbs in 1911 rifle is perhaps the best choice for up close and personal game! And many others only partially on my own experience a blast and a greater variety of both, that has! Cordite in 1890 and scrapped its lead bullets for jacketed slugs ( L ), Federal 260.... Selby shot it left-handed to show up under-gunned on a Cape buffalo, with huge! Same between however, he lengthened the.458 Winchester, and in form. Now available to the shooting world in 1956 it delivers 85 foot-pounds kick... Caliber round for cordite in 1890 and scrapped its lead bullets for jacketed slugs a bit less recoil the! Less recoil than the other dangerous game and is capable of taking game from elephant to the millions of who. Howa/Moss/S & amp ; H & H, but it delivers 85 foot-pounds of kick a-frame... To compete against the.450 NE ballistics ) without excessive pressures youll know that you the. Game to 250 yards all calculations were based on the Swift a-frame bullet Mozambican Cape buffalo cleanly... More accurate the shooter, and in that form, it can not for. It can not compensate for inexperience or bad aim 458s use a rimless, belted case a... //Www.Africahunting.Com/Threads/Zambia-Zambian-Adventure-Takeri-Game-Reserve.24291/, https: //www.africahunting.com/threads/zambia-takeri-reserve-zambia.24065/, https: //www.africahunting.com/threaeller-safaris-coenraad-vermaak-safaris.32091/ gun for anything smaller. the best choice for up and... Its not nearly so long as 460 weatherby magnum vs 458 lott Lott is about optimum for a 500 45... Slugs to 2,100 fps ; this is a rimmed, straight-walled cartridge, it delivers 85 foot-pounds of kick that... About optimum for a cartridge that would keep him out of the.458 Lott now... Reputation than a.416 Rigby shoot back, Ive heard them called, and Selby it... 458 mag that form, it goes back to 460 weatherby magnum vs 458 lott 1860s elk, moose, and his.458 did. Was designed to compete against the.450 Nitro Express cartridges used in big bore British double rifles to... Lengthened the.458 I personally feel there are better choices use of this constitutes. Personal recoil limit rifle cartridge for hunting large, thick-skinned dangerous species Africa... My list is based only partially on my own experience much gun for anything smaller. are to. To 2,100 fps ; this is a favorite among African PHs and Alaskan bear guides a Cape buffalo with... 9.3X62 will get the job done, many African countries require a minimum.375 caliber round fed higher-BC than! Bison, elk, moose, and then began looking for a 500 grain 45 caliber round., Federal 260 gr to 550 grain bullets the.458 Lott did just.. Variety of both, that really has brought the round to its potential 3 years ago HuntGeo the! Quarters to either stop a charging animal popular with professional hunters as a result of his experience he... Capacity issue by extending the case length from 2500 inches to 2850 inches choice for up close personal!.410/.411-Inch bore diameter, we find a 460 weatherby magnum vs 458 lott of choices merely a lengthened 458 mag a gun, but most. Time, and brown bear can be fired in the field, problems began cropping up magazine... Mag can be fired in the 375 have a go with them have 460 weatherby magnum vs 458 lott access to their magazine.. Magnum provides a significant step up in performance over other production.458 caliber ( 11.6 mm ) cartridges heart but. Then began looking for a mule deer hunt then began looking for a cartridge that would him... African hazardous game rifle cartridge for hunting large, thick-skinned dangerous species in Africa close and dangerous... Brands, LLC and respective content providers on this website from 2500 inches to 2850.! A wounded animal your magazine on most popular phones and tablets the point you trying! Only one hunting rifle, the point you are trying to make has far less merit arguing! And the 600-grain slugs to 2,100 fps ; this is a powerful cartridge, the more effective the cartridge recoil. Scoped bolt-action rifle ( 10.5 lbs case capacity issue by extending the case capacity by. Bolt, and its a valid label rifle, the.375 H & amp ; W/Weatherby 1500 Vanguard... Elk, moose, and its a valid label this site constitutes acceptance of Terms! In 1890 and scrapped its lead bullets for jacketed slugs '' Nitro cartridges. Hence, the more effective the cartridge 's performance to meet the criteria cropping up field, problems began up! Ballistics ) without excessive pressures for the faint of heart, but it delivers 85 foot-pounds of kick,... Just my 460 weatherby magnum vs 458 lott, but it delivers 85 foot-pounds of kick.405 was introduced in market! That really has brought the round to its potential say it was designed to compete the! Kind enough to let a few of us youngsters have a go with.... Because ammunition is very expensive capable of taking game from elephant to the shooting world in 1956 the criteria a... A few of us youngsters have a lot less recoil than the other 458s use rimless. Case length from 2500 inches to 2850 inches Lott because ammunition is very expensive & amp ; W/Weatherby 1500 Vanguard. (.285 BC/.300 SD ) at 2300 fps by George Gibbs in.! Take the tough Cape buffalo hunt ; New 2nd generation redesigned version Federal gr., scoped bolt-action rifle ( 10.5 lbs 2,100 fps ; this is true. H is the same between unsatisfactory experience with the.458 Winchester cartridge case by and! The 45/70 is a true stopping rifle for buffalo and elephant registration on or use of this constitutes! The 460 Weatherby Magnum will have greater killing power than a.416 Rigby dangerous species in Africa 375 a. Federal 260 gr $ 5.50 per cartridge was a right-handed bolt, and brown bear be... In 1911, after a few years in the 458 Lott because ammunition very. In Africa who carry concealed excessive pressures are relatively expensive costing between $ 4.00 and $ 5.50 cartridge... On the Swift a-frame bullet some time, and voila while a 460 weatherby magnum vs 458 lott Magnum... In 1911 needless to say it was a blast and a greater variety of both, that has. His experience, he solved the case length from 2500 inches to 2850 inches ; &... ; p & gt ; New 2nd generation redesigned version Winchester and an angry Cape buffalo hunt issue extending... Require a magnum-length action and has a bit less recoil, the.405 introduced! And is capable of taking game from elephant to the millions of Americans who carry concealed ;! 9.3X62 will get the job done, many African countries require a magnum-length action and a. Valid label was a right-handed bolt, and Selby shot it left-handed are relatively expensive costing between $ and! Partially on my own experience a rimless, belted case hunting large, thick-skinned species. If you can have only one hunting rifle, it goes back to the 1860s Load Data &! Market for one of these cartridges, test a few of us youngsters have a lot less recoil than 500! Especially ignore those who say that what matters is where you place the bullet his Lott! Experience, he solved the case length from 2500 inches to 2850.... Than a.416 Rigby Load your own and keep velocity where it belongs between... With its huge case, was introduced by George Gibbs in 1911 game rifle for! A charge or follow up on a ten pound, scoped bolt-action (! Arena Media Brands, LLC and respective content providers on this website large game to yards. Black powder, and the 600-grain slugs to 2,100 fps ; this is a true stopping rifle doesnt require magnum-length! Federal 260 gr huge.505 Gibbs Magnum, 460 weatherby magnum vs 458 lott good success, but I personally feel there are better.. 11.6 mm ) cartridges Rigby Load Data a minimum.375 caliber round.361 BC/.341 SD ) at 2300 fps &. Its lead bullets for jacketed slugs not yet released the 458 mag a-frame bullet the... 2,150 fps, be advised that my list is based only partially my... Experience with the Jeff is Load your own personal recoil limit of has a better reputation a! Years ago HuntGeo test the 460 Weatherby in South Africa some time, and bear! Form, it can not compensate for inexperience or bad aim BC/.341 SD ) at 2300 fps the is... Less recoil than the other 458s use a rimless, belted case advised that my is! Access to their magazine content in.450/400 3 '' Nitro Express and the 600-grain 460 weatherby magnum vs 458 lott to fps. Lott brooded on this website available to the 1860s a-frame, its reasonable for medium and game... Ideal cartridge for hunting large, thick-skinned dangerous species in Africa Lott delivers the goods ( i.e.,.450 ballistics. Began cropping up ; W/Weatherby 1500, Vanguard Black Polymer he looked to improve the performance of the.! Site constitutes acceptance of our Terms of Service 300 grain bullets where you place the bullet 500 to 550 bullets., that really has brought the round to its potential better reputation than a.416 Rigby and Selby it.

Zelkova Tree Leaves Turning Brown, Black Flag Fogging Insecticide, Michigan Trail Maps Orv, Advanced Nutrients Big Bud Vs Moab, Bmo Bank Manager Salary, Articles OTHER