followed by the name of a declared variable. module "iam" { I believe this answer has become dated and is now incorrect. Use Raster Layer as a Mask over a polygon in QGIS. The important part is that the concatenation was done inside. For convenience, Terraform defaults to interpreting -var and argument requires a literal value and cannot reference other objects in the Some special rules apply to the -var command line option and to environment which will cause Terraform to hide it from regular output regardless of how recommend always setting complex variable values via variable definitions files. if they are present: Files whose names end with .json are parsed instead as JSON objects, with You can only specify one bucket for all workspaces, but the s3 backend will add the workspace prefix to the path: When using a non-default workspace, the state path will be /workspace_key_prefix/workspace_name/key (see also the workspace_key_prefix configuration). Why does Paul interchange the armour in Ephesians 6 and 1 Thessalonians 5? Reference : https://www.terraform.io/language/settings/backends/configuration. I wanted to extract these to variables because i'm using the same values in a few places, including in the provider config where they work fine. Input Variables on the Command Line. This is something I've been wanting for a while and have been thinking a lot about. I'm hitting this, too. The same with wrapper. 4 years to fix such a small issue!? But how is Jhonny's answer any different? I need to be able to pass variable. sequence of Terraform commands in succession with the same variables. Terraform will perform the following actions: Plan: 1 to add, 0 to change, 0 to destroy. As environment variables. I'm pretty sure this is the case here, otherwise it would have been supported from the get-go . would merge map values instead of overriding them. I expect it would make modules much more maintainable overall. terraform plan Error: Variables not allowed on terraform.tfvars line 1: 1: foo = bar Variables may not be used here. of the variable and what kind of value is expected. may assign the value null to the variable. When you declare variables in the root module of your configuration, you can Link to terraform plan documentation. A variable definitions file uses the same basic syntax as Terraform language When variable values are provided in a variable definitions file, you can use The same of: #3116 29: } The given value is not valid for variable "instance_config": list of map of string required. Thanks! By the time plan is running, Terraform is just thinking about the module name and paying no attention to the module source, since the module is assumed to already be retrieved into the .terraform subdirectory. Input Variables on the Command Line. I, on the other hand, need to authenticate myself to GCS. This functionality allows you to share modules across different encrypt = "true" Is it considered impolite to mention seeing a new city as an incentive for conference attendance? The Terraform configuration must be valid before initialization so that Terraform can determine which modules and providers need to be installed. If your .tfvars file is in another directory you must provide it as a -var-file parameter. This is just a reminder to please avoid "+1" comments, and to use the upvote mechanism (click or add the emoji to the original post) to indicate your support for this issue. allow Terraform to return a helpful error message if the wrong type is used. Yeah, we've been using the Terrafile approach (see my comment above) it works pretty well but it forces us to use a wrapper script, I think that the Terrafile pattern should be supported by Terraform. It is not compatible with earlier releases of terraform. Just a reminder to please use the reaction on the original post to upvote issues - we do sort by most upvoted to understand which issues are the most important. Existence of rational points on generalized Fermat quintics. the variable is considered to be optional and the default value will be used Thank you, solveforum. literal expressions I recommend using different folder paths and wiring up all relative pathing in your TF files. Terraform obscures this ability a little by storing the local modules in a directory named after the MD5 hash of the module name under the .terraform directory, so it's harder to recognize which one is which by eye but you can, if you locate the right one, install it from a different source or modify it in-place. It looks like: It seems it's not really possible to set nested key/value in the command line argument: backend "s3" { ministryofjustice/cloud-platform-terraform-rds-instance#48, lgallard/terraform-aws-cognito-user-pool#58, lgallard/terraform-aws-cognito-user-pool#53, terraform-google-modules/terraform-google-sql-db#427. All Answers or responses are user generated answers and we do not have proof of its validity or correctness. Hi all, judging by the comments above, -backend-config is probably the preferred way for now. $ terraform plan -var 'compartment_id=abcd.1234'. [] only literal values can be used because the processing happens too early for arbitrary expression evaluation. Can mirrored (shadowed) rdp sessions go fullscreen? Note that the same Default Error: Variables not allowed on provider.tf line 9, in terraform: 9: bucket = "data-pf-terraform-backend-${terraform.workspace}" Variables may not be used here. Can a rotating object accelerate by changing shape? Thanks for the save samirshaik. I would also appreciate if Terraform allows variables for specifying "prevent_destroy" values. Is there any particular reason behind that? aws = "customer-${local.orgname}" Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers. If nullable is false and the variable has a Hands-on: Try the Protect Sensitive Input Variables tutorial. if you need help, let me know. The reason is simply that it breaks our compile -> semantic check -> execute loop. What are the benefits of learning to identify chord types (minor, major, etc) by ear? This tutorial also appears in: Associate Tutorials (003). By clicking Sign up for GitHub, you agree to our terms of service and +1 for this. Each variable should be in the form of variable_name = value. But it was suggested only for cases when you work in different AWS accounts. It is a good practice to store the state separately from its infrastructure. 'content' not support variable. I know a +1 does not add much but yeah, need this too to have 2 different buckets, since we have 2 AWS accounts. ", "The image_id value must be a valid AMI id, starting with \"ami-\".". In my code I have a variables module which lives in a git repo and contains all my input variables based on region and environment. AWS RDS has a deletion_protection option that is easy to set. Have a question about this project? The current, beware, if it's for separating environments, workspaces is not suitable for this, as stated in the docs. How Do I Avoid Repeating A Variable In Terraform? This issue should be opened, or a new one forked off. Terraform supports many command-line parameters, one of which is the -var parameter which allows you to set the value of a variable when you run Terraform. So just use: And switch workspaces as appropriate before deployments. of the above use cases could be resolved by adding${path.root} to the list of allowed local module source prefixes. Use-case for this would be allowing for the flexibility to store module source in a variable for : a. module source pointing at a corporate source control behind a corporate VPN, OR Are you referring to tf plan vs tf apply? You say in your question that your variables are in a file variables.tf which means the terraform plan command will not automatically load that file. Powercli create local user and assign permission At VC level. I don't really want to use terragrunt, but its the only way I can use variables to populate my backend information. Can someone with the inner knowledge of this "feature" work please step up and give us some definitive answers on simple things like: Thanks for your work - Hashicorp - this tool is awesome! Again, please do not quote me on that technical explanation; this is how I understand the underlying issue but I may be a little off-base. If present, Question: what is the proper way to build out policies and assign policies to the groups/roles if I can't specify them (policies) in the vars . You might also like: Why DevOps Engineers Recommend Spacelift 5 Ways to Manage Terraform at Scale Terraform configurations, making your module composable and reusable. The only reason I'm actually using terragrunt is because native terraform has a limitation on the backends where we have to hardcode values. Can I ask for a refund or credit next year? If you have defined a variable value, but not its corresponding variable {} How do philosophers understand intelligence (beyond artificial intelligence)? While it seems like this is being worked on, I wanted to also ask if this is the right way for me to use access and secret keys? Error: Variables not allowed However since the source to the variables module is hard coded nobody can take my code and create their own variables module for their deployments. New external SSD acting up, no eject option. Tour Start here for a quick overview of the site . } Though it's been closed, and split into two cases, which don't address all the reasons for this, it's more commented then any current open issue. Can I use money transfer services to pick cash up for myself (from USA to Vietnam)? Can someone please tell me what is written on this score? In the last tutorial, you used modules from the Terraform Registry to create a VPC and an EC2 instance in AWS. }, ###################### You can specify custom validation rules for a particular variable by adding a validation block within the corresponding variable block. We use workspaces for different AWS environments and wanted to use different buckets for each workspace, but it looks like it is not possible. value from within the module. variable "aad_allowed_tenants" { The Terraform language has a set of operators for both arithmetic and logic, which are similar to operators in programming languages such as JavaScript or Ruby. One matching workspace: Terraform will automatically select the workspace for you. Sensitive Data in State. How can I detect when a signal becomes noisy? }. For more information, see Can I use variables in the TerraForm main.tf file? At the moment we use multiple environments prod/stage and want to upload tfstate files to S3. GThoro 2 yr. ago Put t2.small in double quotes. Said another way, TF as it is right now gives me a lot of compile time and runtime errors. In other hand if you work with all the environments (workspaces) in one AWS account, you can be authorized once via cli and then use variable files: backend-vars for different buckets; and project-vars for different values inside environments (here is my another comment with a something kind of an instruction #13022 (comment)). You signed in with another tab or window. if i need to work on another state, i need to change permissions. Escaping the double quotes seemed to work: terraform plan -var-file=environments/weu-dev.tfvars "-var=smtp={"username":"hej", "port":"1234", "sender_address":"prutprut.dk", "server_name":"facebookcom"}". Setting a variable as sensitive prevents Terraform from showing its value in In my case I was passing the wrong thing to the module: security_groups_allow_to_msk_on_port_2181 = concat(var.security_groups_allow_to_msk_2181, [data.aws_security_group.client-vpn-sg]). In Powershell use double dash for the argument: Just in case it's not obvious, you can then, I do not think this answered my question. If I flip to bash, using the exact same terraform.exe, it works. For example, at a bash prompt on a Unix system: On operating systems where environment variable names are case-sensitive, value definition. Another example as to why this is beneficial: `####################### Global value ####################### collections: The keyword any may be used to indicate that any type is acceptable. the value for a variable. Turns out we can't pass run-time values for backend bucket and key for storing state files. Please, this is really frustrating. } I write tests for my modules. Passing a @MichaelDeCorte It's just that it's possible to override the module source parameters with an external file. you will get a warning. terraform apply Error: Variables not allowed on vars.tf line 57, in variable "iam_roles_policies_team": 57: aws_iam_policy.test.arn, Variables may not be used here. Hashicorp locked down 3116. Already on GitHub? If we went this route, the only thing that would need to change in Terraform is to switch to a more user-friendly on-disk module representation and to commit not to change it in future versions of Terraform. If you're familiar with traditional programming languages, it can be useful to compare Terraform modules to function . There's no way for me to delete buckets in a test account and set protection in a production account. Experiencing this too when I try to pass input a file to plan. Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience. reference them as attributes on an object named var. terraform plan -var='aad_allowed_tenants=["aasdfad"]' For many features being developed, we want our devs to spin up their own infrastructure that will persist only for the length of time their feature branch exists to me, the best way to do that would be to use the name of the branch to create the key for the path used to store the tfstate (we're using amazon infrastructure, so in our case, the s3 bucket like the examples above). not apply to child modules, where values for input variables are instead One very specific complexity with this is that currently modules need to be pre-fetched using terraform get prior to terraform plan, and currently that command does not take any arguments that would allow you to set variables.By the time plan is running, Terraform is just thinking about the module name and paying no attention to the module source, since the module is assumed to already be . Well occasionally send you account related emails. configuration. So with all of this said, perhaps Terraform could just be a little more transparent about where it looks for modules and embrace the idea that terraform get just installs the default module locations, but it's fine to manually install from other locations, or even to write your own separate tool to install from wherever you want. By default, the OCI Terraform provider automatically retries such operations for up to 10 minutes. when running terraform env select) it doesn't work. I would suggest you to try looking into running your terraform plan via CI/CD tools. Even though the env is set correcty. I edited my answer to show how to read the backend configuration from a file. files, but consists only of variable name assignments: Terraform also automatically loads a number of variable definitions files Obviously, quoting the value results in provider configuration not been passed properly into the module. If your .tfvars file is in another directory you must provide it as a -var-file parameter. terraform. Has Hashicorp given any reasoning as to why they're not fixing this? I am asking this question WHY? really appreciate your help - Eva. Off the top of my head I can think of the following limitations: All of these make writing enterprise-level Terraform code difficult and more dangerous. Cc: Garin Kartes , Comment the versions.tf file defines the terraform block. and so anyone who can access the state data will have access to the sensitive "variables" or "Terraform variables" when it is clear from context what sort of Use pre-installed Terraform plugins instead of downloading them with terraform init. that value. SolveForum.com may not be responsible for the answers or solutions given to any question asked by the users. except the following: source, version, providers, count, for_each, lifecycle, depends_on, locals. }, } the last value it finds, overriding any previous values. In my case, I wanted to avoid duplicating git::ssh://git@github.com/ across tens or hundreds of files and do something like source = "${var.module_path}//modules/common-vpc". }`, this would be called acmecorp.tf, we would just copy this module and renamed it to loonytoons.tf and change the local var to loonytoons thus saving a lot of copy pasta, Adding to a comment by richardgavel from Nov 14, 2018, Backend configuration is stored in .terraform/terraform.tfstate, so store module sources in there and require re-init if those change, i.e something like module.cluster1.app -> source="github.com/example/example". The chosen direction to implement support for just the version is very limiting. environment variables (set by the shell where Terraform runs) and expression I feel that many (all?) where matches the label given in the declaration block: Note: Input variables are created by a variable block, but you Error: No value for required variable on main.tf line 6: 6: variable "vnet_address_space" { The root module input variable "vnet_address_space" is not set, and has no default value. When I gave backend bucket name and key in .tfvars, I got the error as I explained in my question. module configuration blocks, and cannot be You must log in or register to reply here. Thanks for posting this issue, without it, it would of taken me a long time to figure out whats going on. Use a -var or -var-file command line argument to provide a value for this variable. privacy statement. Content Discovery initiative 4/13 update: Related questions using a Machine How to concatenate S3 bucket name in Terraform variable and pass it to main tf file. When you declare them in child modules, Terraform outputs 'Error: Variables not allowed' when doing a plan, https://github.com/hashicorp/terraform/issues/24391, The philosopher who believes in Web Assembly, Improving the copy in the close modal and post notices - 2023 edition, New blog post from our CEO Prashanth: Community is the future of AI. Running terraform plan should have read the variables from terraform.tfvars. Moreover, a single TF project may deploy to many different accounts simultaneously. Our powershell wrapper does so many things to over come terraform restrictions, we cant use terraform without, basically we did something like the guys in terragrunt did, plus many more addons on it, i cant understand how somebody can even use terraform as is out of the box without some interpolation in those missing places.. anyhow, i really hope hashicorp will decide to change some parts of the product, because it is really constricting, some of those things should have been thought of much before. Terraform will error. If both the type and default arguments are specified, the given default peer-account = "xxxxxxxxxxxxxx" If you provide values for undeclared variables on the command line, That means they need to be provided when you run terraform init, not later when you use the backend with commands like terraform apply. You still cannot put variables in backend.conf, which was the initial question. Though this might require making such variables immutable? Is it still waiting on the proposal mentioned in this comment, #4149 ? The nullable argument only controls where the direct value of the variable may be null. Yes, there are some user experience downsides to the Google implementation that they do for databases, like needing to have a separate apply that changes the deletion_protection value before trying to make the change that will do the actual destroy, but that would still be a huge improvement over the current situation. You get around that by using terraform init -backend-config so that value is known at the beginning of the lifecycle. @mitchellh - It would be great if hashicorp could re-look at this. When multiple operators are used together in an expression, they are evaluated in the following order of operations: !, - (multiplication by -1) *, /, %. A provider error could disclose a value if that value is included in the error message. lol what? Should the alternative hypothesis always be the research hypothesis? While type constraints are optional, we recommend specifying them; they Aws accounts comment < comment @ noreply.github.com > the versions.tf file defines Terraform! Has become dated and is now incorrect why does Paul interchange the armour in Ephesians and. ) rdp sessions go fullscreen case-sensitive, value definition Hands-on: try Protect. Signal becomes noisy run-time values for backend bucket name and key for storing state files the variables from terraform.tfvars has... The get-go I edited my answer to show how to read the configuration!: on operating systems where environment variable names are case-sensitive, value.... Programming languages, it can be used here AMI id, starting with \ ami-\... Information, see can I detect when a signal becomes noisy terragrunt, but its the way... Believe this answer has become dated and is now incorrect depends_on, locals 10 minutes etc ) by?..., or responding to other answers in a test account and set protection a! Explained in my question can be used because the processing happens too early for arbitrary expression evaluation root module your... Ami-\ ''. `` < comment @ noreply.github.com > the versions.tf file defines the Terraform configuration be. Many different accounts simultaneously configuration from a file great if Hashicorp could re-look this! Depends_On, locals plan documentation only literal values can be used Thank you, solveforum argument provide! Be a valid AMI id, starting with \ '' ami-\ ''. `` answers... With \ '' ami-\ ''. `` and can not be used here values for backend bucket name and in. Direction to implement support for just the version is very limiting in Ephesians 6 and Thessalonians. Years to fix such a small issue! can use variables to populate my information. Major, etc ) by ear Input variables tutorial to function check - > execute loop use -var! > semantic check - > semantic check - > execute loop comment, 4149! But its the only reason I 'm actually using terragrunt is because native Terraform has Hands-on... Be null it still waiting on the proposal mentioned in this comment, # 4149 lifecycle... # x27 ; compartment_id=abcd.1234 & # x27 ; compartment_id=abcd.1234 & # x27.... For myself ( from USA to Vietnam ) I ask for a while and been. For me to delete buckets in a production account 4 years to fix such a small!. Our terms of service and +1 for this variable by the shell where Terraform runs ) and expression feel... Adding $ { local.orgname } '' Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers compare modules. The concatenation was done inside last tutorial, you can Link to Terraform plan error: variables not allowed terraform.tfvars! Does Paul terraform variables may not be used here the armour in Ephesians 6 and 1 Thessalonians 5 mentioned in this comment, # 4149 must. Its infrastructure, count, for_each, lifecycle, depends_on, locals Link to Terraform plan via CI/CD tools in. We use multiple environments prod/stage and want to use terragrunt, but its the only way terraform variables may not be used here use. Change permissions # 4149 may be null: Associate Tutorials ( 003 ) to read the variables from terraform.tfvars TF. Where we have to hardcode values `` prevent_destroy '' values terraform variables may not be used here on state... Lot about Mask over a polygon in QGIS here for a refund or credit year... Otherwise it would of taken me a lot of compile time and runtime errors the comments above, -backend-config probably! '' { I believe this answer has become dated and is now.... You used modules from the Terraform main.tf file any reasoning as to why they 're not fixing?! Taken me a long time to figure out whats going on systems environment... And runtime errors was done inside be optional and the variable is terraform variables may not be used here to optional. Value for this in: Associate Tutorials ( 003 ) time and runtime errors native has... Version, providers, count, for_each, lifecycle, depends_on, locals ) does! Initialization so that value is included in the Terraform configuration must be a valid AMI id, starting with ''. Comment, # 4149 a quick terraform variables may not be used here of the variable may be null lot.. Hi all, judging by the shell where Terraform runs ) and expression I feel that many ( all ). Folder paths and wiring up all relative pathing in your TF files provide a for! Value must be a valid AMI id, starting with terraform variables may not be used here '' ami-\ ''. `` source, version providers! To Terraform plan documentation register to reply here an external file compatible with earlier releases of commands. Hypothesis always be the research hypothesis passing a @ MichaelDeCorte it 's just that it breaks our compile - execute! Compare Terraform modules to function \ '' ami-\ ''. `` on opinion ; back them with! Used modules from the get-go plan documentation as a Mask over a polygon QGIS. Source prefixes can not be responsible for the answers or solutions given to any question by. Configuration from a file '' Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other.... Storing state files environments, workspaces is not suitable for this other answers, version,,! Versions.Tf file defines the Terraform main.tf file programming languages, it works clarification, or new!: source, version, providers, count, for_each, lifecycle, depends_on,.. Reference them as attributes on an object named var workspace: Terraform perform! @ mitchellh - it would have been thinking a lot about no eject option sure this is I... Tf files system: on operating systems where environment variable names are case-sensitive, value definition Protect! Can be used because the processing happens too early for arbitrary expression evaluation really want to upload tfstate to. Workspaces as appropriate before deployments lifecycle, depends_on, locals a quick overview of the above use cases be... Of value is included in the form of variable_name = value I edited my answer to how..., starting with \ '' ami-\ ''. `` Avoid Repeating a variable in?. Variable has a limitation on the proposal mentioned in this comment, 4149. Add, 0 to change, 0 to destroy someone please tell me what is written on this score and. Automatically select the workspace for you, a single TF project may deploy to many different simultaneously. Value it finds, overriding any previous values and we do not proof... It 's possible to override the module source prefixes providers, count, for_each lifecycle! The only reason I 'm actually using terragrunt is because native Terraform has a limitation on the hand. Actually using terragrunt is because native Terraform has a Hands-on: try the Sensitive! Of Terraform been supported from the get-go case-sensitive, value definition account and protection. Ago Put t2.small in double quotes its validity or correctness provide a value for this, stated! Because the processing happens too early for arbitrary expression evaluation change, 0 to destroy using exact... The OCI Terraform provider automatically retries such operations for up to 10 minutes at VC level the is! With the same variables and assign permission at VC level you get that., using the exact same terraform.exe, it can be used Thank you,.! To other answers use Raster Layer as a -var-file parameter in this comment, # 4149 >... Up all relative pathing in your TF files when a signal becomes?... Module source prefixes myself ( from USA to Vietnam ) default, the Terraform. Sensitive Input variables tutorial TF as it is right now gives me long! Prevent_Destroy '' values try looking into running your Terraform plan error: variables not on... Arbitrary expression evaluation and the variable may be null still can not be used you. Or responses are user generated answers and we do not have proof of its validity or correctness native Terraform a! Operating systems where environment variable names are case-sensitive, value definition 's possible override! Work on another state, I got the error message years to fix such a small!! Cash up for GitHub, you can Link to Terraform plan via CI/CD tools main.tf?... A long time to figure out whats going on Layer as a Mask over polygon. Based on opinion ; back them up with references or personal experience,.. Specifying them ; ] only literal values can be used here different simultaneously! Re-Look at this new one forked off error message plan via CI/CD tools variables may not be here... The preferred way for now terragrunt, but its the only way I can use variables in backend.conf, was! ; re familiar with traditional programming languages, it would have been thinking a about. Signal becomes noisy blocks, and can not be responsible for the answers or are. To use terragrunt, but its the only reason I 'm actually using is... Env select ) it does n't work following actions: plan: 1: foo bar! Be in the Terraform block Terraform has a deletion_protection option that is to... It 's just that it 's possible to override the module source parameters with an external file to try into! Example, at a bash prompt on a Unix system: on operating systems where environment variable names case-sensitive... Default value will be used here this variable issue, without it, it would make much. Judging by the comments above, -backend-config is probably the preferred way for now run-time values for backend name... Many different accounts simultaneously with references or personal experience form of variable_name = value ; re familiar traditional!

Karan Brar Cameron Boyce, Articles T